The Toadies
Every so often, I get reminded of how cool it is to do this job. The Toadies have been on near-constant rotation for me for decades, so getting to sit down with long-time drummer Mark Reznicek was a genuine thrill. The Texas band’s latest album, The Charmer, is out now, and it was recorded with the late Steve Albini, a producer the band had wanted to work with for more than 30 years. We talked about tape and razor blades, how people listen to albums now, the 90s, vinyl and what makes the Toadies sound like the Toadies.
Back to tape with Steve Albini
Technology keeps changing, but the technology of a rock band seems pretty consistent: guitars, drums, maybe some keys. Have you found much change in how a band plays?
For us, it’s still two guitars, bass and drums, basically. Pretty analog on our end. In the past we’ve had a very little use of synth and stuff, but not much, really. So I think it’s more about how the music gets recorded. Our first album, which we recorded in 1993, was all recorded to two-inch tape and edited with a razor blade, and by the time we recorded our second album, Pro Tools was coming in.
Pretty much everything we recorded in the 21st century has been digital, until this latest album with Steve Albini. He was strictly, strictly analog. So it was back to two-inch tape and razor blades, and I found it pretty refreshing. There are definitely some advantages to recording digitally, as far as editing or splicing two different takes together. But in this case we rehearsed and really drilled, so we had the songs down, and we just went in the studio and recorded them. And really, I think that’s the best way. That’s how it should be done.
Albums as a journey
How has streaming and downloading affected the way you write and record an album, from track order to mastering?
I’m not sure it changed, really. I know the way people listen to music now is kind of piecemeal. Not everybody listens to an entire album in a sitting, and I’m guilty of that sometimes myself, taking your favourite songs and putting them on a playlist. But for the Toadies, we’ve always looked at our albums as a whole, as a listening experience in itself. It takes you on a journey, the way a good album should.
It’s like a live set list. It’s not front-loaded with all the fast songs and then the slow ones in the middle. It has to meander and evolve and change the mood from song to song. That’s what an album does.
Do you have an example of what you think is a perfect album?
Oh, wow. I think there are a lot. Paul McCartney’s Ram is one of my favourites. I guess it’s actually Paul and Linda McCartney’s Ram. For me there are no skips on it, and it’s very eclectic. There’ll be a rock song followed by an acoustic, mellow song followed by an orchestral epic, and it definitely keeps your attention from beginning to end.
Thirty years of Rubberneck
You’ve been playing songs from Rubberneck for decades. Do you play them differently than you did 30 years ago?
It’s kind of interesting. A few years ago we did an anniversary tour for that album where we played the whole thing in sequence. When we were getting ready, I went back and listened to the album, which I hadn’t done in a long time. Before I listened, I thought, yeah, I still play it the way I recorded it. Then I found I’d changed some things, maybe added some things or taken things away.
It was kind of eye-opening. Over time the basic structure and tempo stay the same, but there are slight variations I’ve added over the years. So I thought, “Okay, I’m going to go back to playing it the way I originally did.” That was three or four years ago, and since then it’s already evolved in a different way. I don’t know that the average listener would notice, but I notice it. I might play a fill slightly differently.
The 90s and the streaming age
The era of 90s alternative rock is romanticised now. Do you look back fondly on the industry back then?
I look back fondly. There are major differences. That was before streaming or downloads, so you had to be more intentional with your music purchases. You had to physically go to a store to buy a certain album, or go and browse knowing you’d come home with something. Now you can do that sitting on your couch.
In a certain sense, people had a stronger connection to the music because they drove to the record store, chose that particular album and came home and listened to it. Nowadays you dial it up on your phone, and you might enjoy it, but there’s a bigger chance you’ll forget about it by the next day because something else has popped up on your radar to take its place.
Why The Charmer is his favourite
Of all the Toadies albums you’ve been part of, do you have a favourite?
I know it’s probably a cliché to say the most recent one, but we recorded with Albini. When we first got signed to a major label to record Rubberneck, they asked us who we wanted to produce it, and we said Albini. They had a million reasons why we shouldn’t use him. So it’s been more than 30 years that we’ve wanted to work with Steve.
Also, the label we’d been on until a few years ago dissolved. The owner decided he didn’t want to do it anymore, so we were without a label, but we knew we wanted to make an album. We saved up the money we made playing shows to finance the record ourselves. We paid for the recording, the mixing and the mastering before we had a label. So it’s ours. Afterwards we shopped it around to see if anyone wanted to release it. That makes it more personal to me.
The lyrics Vaden wrote come from a really personal place, dealing with mental health issues he’s struggled with his whole life, that a lot of people struggle with. Him being vulnerable in that way makes it a pretty special album. But Rubberneck, we wouldn’t have a career if that hadn’t been a big success in the mid-90s, specifically the song “Possum Kingdom”. The first one’s always special, and the latest one’s always special.
Pixies meets ZZ Top
I describe the Toadies to people as “swampy grunge”. How do you describe the sound?
That’s a fair description. Before I joined, they were one of many local bands around Dallas/Fort Worth, and I latched on to them because they seemed unique. There were elements of punk rock and even some metal. What you’re calling “swampy” is the sound of Texas blues. A song like “I Come from the Water” from Rubberneck has that swing and blues feel, and in that era of grunge nobody else was really bringing that element. It’s like if you combine the Pixies with ZZ Top, two of my favourites. That’s the Toadies DNA right there.
Being from Texas, that music surrounds us, country and blues, and we’re not that far from New Orleans. In Texas it’s hot more often than it’s any other temperature, and that humidity seeps into the music itself.
For another conversation with a band still going strong decades in, read our Good Charlotte interview with Paul Thomas.
Credit: Racket Magazine
