Jerry Hall was right all along, and viewers never got to see it. Days after Celebrity Traitors ended, James Acaster has revealed that the supermodel confronted him face to face and accused him of being a Traitor, and that he more or less told her she was correct. The scene was cut from the BBC broadcast.
Acaster shared the story on Alan Carr’s podcast Life’s a Beach, released on 2 November, in a conversation about their experiences on the show. Carr won last year’s inaugural series.
What James Acaster said about Jerry Hall
“They cut out [a scene where] Jerry Hall went right up to me face to face, this close, accused me of being a Traitor,” Acaster said, as reported by HuffPost UK. According to the comedian, Hall told him: “I think it’s James.”
Sticking to his strategy of always telling the truth, he replied: “I think it might be me as well, Jerry.” She told him “You’re very sneaky,” and he answered: “I am sneaky, and it could be me.”
“And then she was like, ‘Mmm’, and then went away,” he said. “I went, ‘Surely that’s going in the edit’. No! Nowhere to be seen!”
The Independent quoted a slightly different version of the same exchange: “I looked her in the eye and said, ‘I think it might be me too, Jerry,’ and she said, ‘You’re very sneaky.’ And I told her I was very sneaky and it might be me.”
Why Hall never followed it up
HuffPost UK noted that Hall, known in the castle as something of a wildcard, was banished by her fellow Faithfuls before she could pursue her theory any further. Metro said that unlike some of the other Faithfuls, Hall, 70, had caught on to Acaster’s game well before his bombshell roundtable moment.
It is a twist that would have changed how many viewers saw the series. Hall’s hunches were often treated as random, yet on the biggest call of the game she had read the room correctly.
“I said a lot more around that roundtable than the edit would suggest”
Acaster, 41, also told Carr that much of what he said at the roundtable never reached screens. “I said a lot more around that roundtable than the edit would suggest,” he said, according to The Independent. “Most of the time, they want to keep how the Traitors vote as a surprise. They don’t want to be like there’s hints that I might go one way or the other. So a lot of the time what I said at the roundtable is cut out.”
That explanation fits with the way the format works. Producers keep the Traitors’ choices hidden to protect the tension of each banishment vote, so hints dropped by players can end up on the cutting room floor.
The confession that shocked viewers
Acaster made history in the penultimate episode by admitting to his fellow contestants at the roundtable that he was a Traitor, a move The Independent described as “unprecedented.” Metro said he did what no Traitor had ever done before and unmasked himself. We covered the night in our report on James Acaster’s confession and the final.
Reports that filming was halted
Viewers had speculated that a lot of footage was edited out, amid a report in The Sun that filming had to be halted after Acaster became “distressed,” The Independent reported. The BBC issued a statement after the penultimate episode aired: “Our highest priority is always the safety and welfare of everyone taking part.” A Celebrity Traitors representative told HuffPost UK that players “are closely monitored and supported throughout by production, which includes a dedicated and experienced welfare team.” Acaster’s team had no comment when contacted by HuffPost UK.
How the series ended
In the finale, Faithfuls Romesh Ranganathan and Sebastian “Bash” Croft won after banishing the remaining Traitors, Maya Jama and King Kenny, The Independent reported. Read more on how Romesh Ranganathan and Bash Croft won.
Jama later reflected on Acaster’s confession in an interview with Variety. “I know, bless him,” the Love Island host said, as quoted by The Independent. Her wider thoughts on the game are in our Maya Jama Celebrity Traitors interview.
Why this cut scene matters
Reality fans love a “what we didn’t see” story, and this one lands because it rewrites a character arc. Hall exits the series looking like a lucky guesser who never quite got there. Acaster’s account suggests she had the right name, heard something close to a confession and simply ran out of time.
It also adds to the growing picture of how much the Celebrity Traitors edit shapes what audiences think happened. From now on, players and viewers alike will be paying closer attention to the scenes that never air.
James Acaster and Jerry Hall: FAQ
What did Jerry Hall say to James Acaster on Celebrity Traitors?
According to Acaster, she went face to face with him and said ‘I think it’s James’, accusing him of being a Traitor, HuffPost UK reported.
How did James Acaster respond to Jerry Hall?
He told her ‘I think it might be me as well, Jerry’, and when she called him sneaky he said he was and that it could be him.
Why was the scene cut?
It is not officially known. Acaster said producers usually want to keep how the Traitors vote a surprise, so much of what he said at the roundtable was cut.
Where did James Acaster reveal the story?
On Alan Carr’s podcast Life’s a Beach, released on 2 November.
Who won Celebrity Traitors?
Faithfuls Romesh Ranganathan and Sebastian ‘Bash’ Croft, after banishing Maya Jama and King Kenny, The Independent reported.
Sources
- HuffPost UK
- The Independent
- Metro
