Is a man made of willow the most unlikely romantic lead of 2026? Quite possibly. Our Wicker review round-up looks at how critics have reacted to Olivia Colman’s bawdy folk-horror fairy tale, which opened in UK cinemas on 30 October, just in time for Halloween weekend. The short version: they mostly love it, with a few reservations.
What is Wicker about?
Without giving too much away, Wicker follows a lonely Fisherwoman who lives on the edge of a medieval village, mocked by her neighbours for her smell and her lack of a husband. When the village’s marriage rituals mark her out as next to wed, which the locals see as a bad omen, she takes matters into her own hands. She commissions the local Basket Weaver to make her a husband out of wicker.
What arrives is kind, devoted and very good at fixing roofs. Before long the happy couple are the talk of the village, and not everyone is pleased. The film is based on Ursula Wills’s short story The Wicker Husband, which has previously been turned into a stage musical with puppetry.
Who is in it?
- Olivia Colman as the Fisherwoman
- Alexander Skarsgård as the Wicker Husband
- Peter Dinklage as the Basket Weaver
- Elizabeth Debicki as the Tailor’s Wife
- Richard E Grant as the Doctor
- Phil Daniels as the Butcher
- Plus Marli Siu, Nabhaan Rizwan, Gustav Lindh, Ella Bruccoleri, Ben Ashenden and Kiell Smith-Bynoe
Richard E Grant fans will appreciate the timing. Having just been the first Traitor banished from this year’s Celebrity Traitors, he plays a doctor who is, by most accounts, even worse at his job than he was at secret-keeping.
The critics’ verdict
Reviews have been strongly positive. On Rotten Tomatoes, the film has sat in the mid-90s per cent from around 150 critics, and Metacritic gives it a score of around 70 out of 100, which counts as “generally favourable”.
The Rotten Tomatoes critics’ consensus sums it up neatly: “Wicker is a charming fable that strikes the right balance between naughty and nice, drawing much of its appeal from deftly deployed salty humor, seamless creature effects, and Olivia Colman’s eminently lovable performance.”
What critics loved
- Colman. Unsurprisingly, the Oscar winner is singled out again and again. She makes the Fisherwoman funny, prickly and deeply sympathetic.
- Skarsgård and the effects. Playing a character entirely covered by a woven suit and mask is a huge ask, and the creature work, developed with Weta Workshop, has been widely praised as seamless.
- The bawdy humour. Wicker is a grown-up film with a cheeky streak, and the salty comedy has gone down well. This is not one for the kids.
The reservations
Not everything works for everyone. Some reviewers felt the script was a little thin and the pacing uneven, particularly as the story shifts from comedy towards darker territory. If you go in expecting a full-on horror film, you may also be surprised: it is more fable than fright-fest.
Audiences seem to agree
It is not only the critics. Audiences polled by PostTrak in the US gave the film a 92 per cent positive score, with 72 per cent saying they would definitely recommend it. The film’s Letterboxd page has also become a mini event of its own, with users suggesting alternative titles such as “John Wicker” and “Fifty Shades of Hay”.
Box office so far
Wicker opened in the US on 23 October from 1,471 cinemas. It had been projected to take $6–8 million in its first weekend but debuted with $5.7 million, finishing fifth in a crowded weekend. It was up against a busy slate that included DC’s Clayface, Klara and the Sun, Wildwood and the return of Sacha Baron Cohen’s Ali G in Ali G: Who Iz I?, so a top-five finish for a quirky adult fable is far from a disaster. With a reported budget of around $10 million, it had taken roughly $9 million worldwide by late October, before opening in the UK. Its UK run and an Australian release on 5 November should push that figure higher.
From Sundance to Sitges
The film has had a long festival road. It premiered at the Sundance Film Festival on 24 January 2026, where Black Bear Pictures picked it up before acquiring North American rights at the European Film Market in February. It also closed the 59th Sitges Film Festival in Spain, one of Europe’s best-known genre festivals, on 18 October.
Behind the camera
Wicker is written and directed by Alex Huston Fischer and Eleanor Wilson, adapting Wills’s story. It was shot in Budapest, with cinematography by Lol Crawley and music by Anna Meredith. Colman also serves as a producer, alongside her husband Ed Sinclair and a long list of partners. The BBFC has rated it 15, and it runs for 105 minutes.
Dev Patel was originally attached to play the Wicker Husband before Skarsgård took over the role.
Who should see it?
Wicker will suit anyone who likes their fairy tales with teeth. Fans of Colman’s sharper comic work will have a great time, and so will anyone who enjoyed Skarsgård in last year’s British indie Pillion, in which he played a leather-clad dom opposite Harry Melling. It is also a good pick for a grown-up date night: a romance that is funny, a bit rude and not afraid to get dark. It is less suited to anyone squeamish about frank sex comedy, or anyone hoping for wall-to-wall scares.
Is it the Halloween film of the year?
That depends on what you want from Halloween. If you want jump scares, there are scarier options, and the folk-horror revival has plenty of grimmer offerings, from Robert Eggers’s upcoming Werwulf (we covered Ethel Cain’s song for its soundtrack) to countless creepy-village thrillers.
If you want something atmospheric, funny, a little filthy and surprisingly moving, Wicker is a very easy recommendation. It has a misty seaside village, a witchy outsider, an angry mob and a man who could go up in flames at any moment. That is plenty of Halloween for most of us.
Our take
Wicker is a reminder that British cinema does odd, adult fairy tales better than almost anyone. It has the bones of a classic folk tale and the soul of a very rude British comedy, and it is anchored by a lead performance that deserves a big audience. It will not be for everyone, but those who click with it seem to fall hard.
Want the full critical picture? Rotten Tomatoes has collected the first reviews here.
Naughty, nice and woven with real feeling. Wicker might be the only film this Halloween where the scariest thing in the village is the neighbours.
